| Rnd | Team | Match Date | Home Team | Result | Away Team |
|---|
| 2 | Fourth XI | 1957-10-19 | Murrumbeena |  | Brighton |
| 149 E Watson 42 B McAlister 33 | | 91 H Wilde 4/14 K Berry 3/16
and 49 K Berry 6/14 |
| 5 | Fourth XI | 1957-11-30 | McKinnon | | Murrumbeena |
| 111 | | 139 D McDermott 42 J Macwhirter 43 Jack Hindmarsh 25
and 4/165 D McDermott 112 B McAlister 45* |
| 6 | Fourth XI | 1957-12-14 | Murrumbeena | lost to | Hampton |
| 137 G Browne 36 B McAlister 26
and 4/71 D McDermott 25 | | 191 J Macwhirter 2/43 E Watson 2/16 K Kennedy 2/26 H Wilde 3/15
and 111 G Browne 2/13 Jack Hindmarsh 2/22 A Watson 2/29 |
